bLAWg, bLOG, BLAHg Rotating Header Image

R.I.P. William J. Sheaffer, Esq.

I have been informed that Mr. Sheaffer is being given the option of either resigning from the Florida Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers or being expelled.

So I only have one question Mr. Sheaffer, was it worth it?

So I only have one question Mr. Sheaffer, was it worth it?

Was it worth sullying your reputation among every criminal defense lawyer in the state just so Kathy Belich could get a story? Was it worth having your claims of “professionalism” published on Mr. Boedeker’s blog on the same day you sold out an entire organization.

You may be an Internet sensation and a media darling, but you are a disgrace to your colleagues. Good job.

You may me an Internet sensation and a media darling, but you are a disgrace to your colleagues. Good job.

And for those that are interested, I did verify that Mr. Sheaffer lied to obtain the seminar materials. Apparently FACDL was concerned that the audio would be leaked, so they set up a system to stream the audio.

Mr. Sheaffer called FACDL headquarters and claimed he was having a hard time hearing the audio and would like to have a copy sent to him. He went so far as to say he needed it so that he could maintain his death penalty qualifications.

FACDL believed Mr. Sheaffer and sent him the audio as he requested – he immediately turned it over to Ms. Belich. The rest is history – just like his reputation among his colleagues.

The rest is history – just like his reputation among his colleagues.

As a side-note, I was informed that when this situation was brought to the attention of the News Director for WFTV-ABC, he was the consummate professional and removed all references at the request of FACDL. I would like to not only commend him for that, I would like to say thank you.

I would like to say thank you.

393 Comments

  1. patsy says:

    So I only have one question Mr. Sheaffer, was it worth it?

    So I only have one question Mr. Sheaffer, was it worth it?

    Was
    Well Mr and I use that term loosely… how do you feel now that the little Momma’s boy went running to the teacher… Teacher teacher look what he did… see how good I am….. GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

  2. loves2shop says:

    Anyone can get it on You Tube..
    search Andrea Lyons it’s about the 4th or 5th one down.. look for Part 1 and Part 2, she is lecturing, so it is in Audio..
    “just saying”…

  3. Frosty says:

    This is a sad day.:( :( and Is A lost to the Florida law community . Everyone makes mistakes. Even lawyers. Dang.

    I would feel the same way if it was You Mr.Hornsby. I REPEAT, what a sad sad day.:(

  4. Gahoundawg says:

    What exactly were you or the Association trying to hide?

  5. Gahoundawg :

    What exactly were you or the Association trying to hide?

    It is not that we were trying to hide anything – it is that people talk candidly at seminars. And when you are among your colleagues, you assume they will not sell you out.

    Mr. Sheaffer violated the trust of an entire organization. It really is that simple.

  6. OMG says:

    @Gahoundawg

    Dawg they didn’t want anyone to know what a sleez lyon is, that’s all.

  7. Frosty says:

    @Gahoundawg

    Both sides the Prosecutors and the defense lawyers have these seminars.They are a place for them to bounce strategies ,idea’s, and tactics on how to build the best possible case.

    It is a place for each side to feel secure enough to relax and learn from each other.It is not one-sided as WFTV.COM made it out to be.

  8. loves2shop says:

    Richard Hornsby wrote:
    @Question
    Only one problem with that theory – CBS is the one news station I have NEVER given provided commentary for.

    Now as a sidenote, I have given commentary for WFTV-ABC; but interestingly, once they put Mr. Sheaffer on their payroll, they never called me again :-(

    ///////////////////

    Is this what it has all been about?? Him getting the job there on WFTV, and them not calling you to be on the show anymore ??

    You said the above on your blog entitled: OMG! Bill YOu did not do what I think you did?

  9. Justiceseeker says:

    Mr. Hornsby there only a few people that should be ashamed over the events of the last few days, one of which is YOU. The other are the defense lawyers representing Casey. Andrea L. is obviously ashamed of her comments made about Jurors and female prosecutors. I would expect more from a “professional” and I use that term lightly. When “officers of the court” can degrade others of the profession using the terms Andrea did, NONE of us are served from her presence.

    That being said, your behavior over Mr. Scheaffer’s comments are below professional and as far as I am concerned no TV station in Orlando, or anywhere else, should ever allow you to speak out on legal matters on their station again.

  10. Pip says:

    Well christ on crutches. Let’s just hope you two don’t inadvertently run into the same Starbuck’s for a quick Grande Skinny Vanilla latte’ anytime soon. Is Orlando gonna be big enough for you two bad boys? hehe. Shitstorm in Or-lawn-do.

  11. Clover says:

    The FACDL needed to be concerned the audio would be released. It was a disgraceful lecuture and the public’s reaction was justifiable outrage. What do you mean he sold out your organization? Mr. Sheaffer exposed something ugly about defense tactics and as far as I am concerned he should have “whistle blower” protection.

  12. @Justiceseeker
    Trust me, I will sleep soundly if exposing a fraud within my ranks means I never appear on television again.

  13. Darlene Chalut says:

    Hornsby – You are NO media Darling! You’re a pathetic jackass

  14. Frosty says:

    You guys do not understand, the ramifications of those recordings being release are going to be felt in the law community from USA to Canada.

    It would be obtuse to think the Prosecution did not have speakers whom stood up among their peers and did not say something negative about a judge,or defense attorneys they have faced.

    That is Just one of the reasons that a disclosure agreement is signed when you attend.

    For me it is not who released it, but the fact it was released.

  15. Clover says:

    What? Not trying to hide anything? Of course you are trying to hide things !!!! Things like defense attorney’s who call jurors killers and trash female prosectors. Just admit it. It’s okay if you want hide it. Just admit it.